Real Estate with JB Realty logo – header image branding

Why Homes Feel Costly Now: How Buyers Can Respond

image

Homes feel expensive for a simple reason: supply hasn’t kept up with demand. Online chatter often blames “big investors,” but national data shows that’s not the primary driver. In Hillsborough and Pinellas, the neighborhoods with tighter inventory still command firmer pricing, while higher-supply pockets give qualified buyers more leverage. Watch our quick strategy clip: September 2025 Market Update | How buyers and sellers can win now.

FHFA House Price Index — Data & Reports

What the narratives get wrong

Many people assume investors are the main reason homes feel unaffordable. Survey results show that belief is widespread, but the market story is mostly about chronic undersupply and sticky owner “lock-in.” As more listings return, the power balance varies block by block.

Bar chart showing 48 percent of Americans blaming investors for high housing costs

How to read Tampa Bay’s signals

Treat each micro-area like its own market. Compare your target homes to the freshest pendings and the best active comps. In buyer-friendly pockets, aim for clean terms plus targeted credits or buydowns that lower total monthly cost without weakening your position. For step-by-step planning, read Why Buyers Finally Have Time To Shop Smart.

What to do next

  • Refresh preapproval so payments reflect today’s quotes and fees.
  • Ask your lender for side-by-side buydown vs. price-cut scenarios in writing.
  • Time your offer as days-on-market rise and feedback repeats across comps.

Key takeaways

  • Perceived “investor blame” is less important than the local supply picture.
  • Micro-market comps and current pendings should drive price and terms.
  • Clean offers plus targeted credits help you win without overpaying.

Your First Home

2025 Edition

Cover of A Guide to Buying Your First Home by JB Realty for Tampa Bay homebuyersDownload

Buying a Home

Winter 2025

Download

Selling Your House

Winter 2025

Download

Articles

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.